The Big Picture, part 2: where we edit and submit a picture book for publication

When it comes to the art of picture book submissions, crafting the perfect pitch can feel like a daunting task. Beth McMullen and Lisa Schmid, the seasoned hosts of a renowned podcast, recently dedicated an episode to demystifying this very process, offering invaluable advice to writers both new and seasoned. In a blend of wit and wisdom, they discussed the intricacies of manuscript polishing, the selection of comparable titles, and the emotional rollercoaster that is the submission process

One of the key takeaways from this episode was the importance of distilling your story into a pitch that's as compelling as those found on Netflix or Amazon. Beth and Lisa stressed the necessity of being concise, especially when it comes to pitching to agents or editors. They also highlighted the benefits of tools like Query Tracker, albeit with a warning about its potential to become an obsessive habit. The conversation was peppered with personal anecdotes, making the advice not only practical but relatable.

Further into the episode, the hosts candidly discussed the selection of publishers and the significance of ensuring that your work aligns with their catalog. The nuanced conversation around choosing recent and relevant comparable titles ('comps') was particularly insightful. They even debated the merits of beloved classics versus newer titles, adding a layer of friendly banter to the mix.

Another focal point of the episode was the strategic use of art notes in a manuscript. Beth and Lisa illuminated how art notes, when used judiciously, can clarify your vision without impeding the illustrator's creativity. They provided guidance on how to include these effectively, ensuring that the story is enhanced rather than restricted by such directions.

The hosts also paid homage to industry figures like author Bitsy Kemper, whose resources and support play a pivotal role in the lives of picture book authors. Bitsy Kemper's curated list of publishers accepting unagented manuscripts was particularly emphasized as a valuable tool for writers embarking on the submission journey.

In summary, the episode served as a comprehensive guide to the picture book submission process, filled with humor and firsthand experiences. The hosts’ open-hearted sharing of their own journeys added depth to the conversation, making the episode a treasure trove of insights for any writer looking to polish and pitch their picture book manuscript with confidence.

For writers looking to delve into the enchanting world of picture books, this podcast episode is a must-listen. Beth McMullen and Lisa Schmidt have crafted a resource that is as entertaining as it is educational, promising to guide you through the labyrinth of submissions with laughter and expertise. The candid nature of their discussion makes it an exceptional companion for any author on the path to publication.